
Symantha Winters, 48 – body found 06/06/07 in Lebanon TN; Sara Nicole Hulbert, 25 – body found 06/26/07; Nashville TN; Lucille “Gretna” Carter, 44 – body found 07/01/07, Birmingham AL; Carma Purpura, 31 – remains have not yet been located; last seen Indianapolis IN
Bruce Mendenhall, 56 – trucker and alleged serial-killer charged with criminal homicide in four murders; currently jailed in Tennessee; charges there; facing the death penalty; suspected in other states; additional charges August 2008; on trial for plotting to arrange the killings of the two detectives who arrested him and three witnesses in his murder case
Nashville, TN
Bruce Mendenhall, 56 – trucker and alleged serial-killer charged with criminal homicide in four murders; currently jailed in Tennessee; charges there; facing the death penalty; suspected in other states; additional charges August 2008; on trial for plotting to arrange the killings of the two detectives who arrested him and three witnesses in his murder case
Nashville, TN
A Davidson County Criminal Court jury convicted Bruce Mendenhall of three counts of solicitation to commit first-degree murder. Mendenhall was found not guilty on two other counts. Mendenhall was convicted of trying to hire a fellow prisoner to kill three people he knew and blamed in part for his arrest on a murder charge. He was found not guilty of trying to hire someone to kill two Metro police detectives.
The trial began on Monday, and closing arguments ended Friday afternoon. The jury deliberated about three hours before returning its verdict. Criminal Court Judge Steve Dozier will sentence Mendenhall on Feb. 26. Each count carries a sentence of 8-12 years.
Mendenhall is scheduled to be tried on May 10, 2010, in the June 2007 slaying of Sarah Hulbert, whose body was found at a truck stop near downtown Nashville.
The prosecution rested its case Thursday afternoon in the trial regarding Bruce Mendenhall’s alleged murders-for-hire. Tennessee Department of Correction inmate Michael Ray Jenkins spent all morning on the stand. He is a witness for the prosecution but has a long criminal history dating back to 1980 and is an admitted substance abuser.
In testimony, Jenkins related that he spent some time on the same cell block with Mendenhall and was aware that Mendenhall became upset when he discovered that another inmate had been secretly recording the inmates’ conversations with Mendenhall and cooperating with police and prosecutors.
In testimony, Jenkins said that Mendenhall became visibly angry and that Jenkins asked if there was anything he could do to help. Mendenhall allegedly told Jenkins that he wanted someone to kill two police officers — the police officers that had questioned him and then arrested him on murder charges.
On cross-examination, the defense asked why the cellmate waited to give information to police. “What I am asking you is when people don’t come forward with information right away, they don’t look credible, do they?” said the defense.
The prosecution rested its case Thursday afternoon in the trial regarding Bruce Mendenhall’s alleged murders-for-hire. Tennessee Department of Correction inmate Michael Ray Jenkins spent all morning on the stand. He is a witness for the prosecution but has a long criminal history dating back to 1980 and is an admitted substance abuser.
In testimony, Jenkins related that he spent some time on the same cell block with Mendenhall and was aware that Mendenhall became upset when he discovered that another inmate had been secretly recording the inmates’ conversations with Mendenhall and cooperating with police and prosecutors.
In testimony, Jenkins said that Mendenhall became visibly angry and that Jenkins asked if there was anything he could do to help. Mendenhall allegedly told Jenkins that he wanted someone to kill two police officers — the police officers that had questioned him and then arrested him on murder charges.
According to Jenkins, Mendenhall had indicated in phone calls Jenkins overheard that Mendenhall was about to come into some money, presumably from an insurance policy on Mendenhall’s wife, who had just died.
Mendenhall indicated that he was interested in having Jenkins do the murders for $15,000, said Jenkins, who said he had indicated that he wasn’t sure anyone would do the killing for that amount of money.
Jurors listened to hours of audio tapes Wednesday in the trial of accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall. Prosecutors said the tapes prove the truck driver tried to have three witnesses killed in the Sara Hulbert case.
Mendenhall is accused of killing Hulbert and prostitutes in several states. Prosecutors put former Metro Jail inmate Roy McLaughlin on the stand Wednesday.
McLaughlin sent police a letter telling them Mendenhall wanted some witnesses killed. Police put a hidden microphone on him, not once but twice. There was video of the two talking in the recreation yard of the jail.
Prosecutors said Mendenhall wanted Lori Young, her son Ritchie Keim and David Powell killed. They’re witnesses in the Hulbert case.
Hulbert’s body was discovered at a downtown Nashville truck stop in the summer of 2007. A few weeks later police arrested Mendenhall at the same truck stop and charged him with the murder.
Testimony has started in the first trial of accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall, the truck driver accused of murdering prostitutes in several states, including Tennessee. The trial is not about those murders, it’s about allegations that Mendenhall tried to hire someone to kill Metro detectives and witnesses in the Sara Hulbert case. The state has been presenting it’s case and calling witnesses since about 10 a.m. Tuesday. They’re relying on the testimony and recordings of two Metro jail inmates. One of them wore a wire.
The other inmate sent a letter to Metro Police Chief Ronal Serpas. The prosecution’s first witness was Metro Cold Case detective Pat Postiglione. The detective told jurors how he and Detective Lee Freeman arrested Mendenhall at the Truck Stops of America in July 2007.
Mendenhall was charged with killing Sara Hulbert. Her body was found at the same truck stop a few weeks earlier. Almost a year later in May 2008, Postiglione said he received a letter from Metro Jail inmate Roy McLaughlin.
The inmate wrote that Mendenhall wanted to kill three witnesses in the Hulbert case, Lori Young, Ritchie Keim and David Powell.
A former truck driver accused of being a serial killer is facing trial this week for trying to contract hits on police officers and witnesses tied to his bizarre legal situation. Bruce Mendenhall has been in jail in Davidson County, TN, since July 2007 after being charged for the deaths of four women, including Sara Hulbert, Symantha Winters, Lucille “Gretna” Carter and Carma Purpora. Police suspect his involvement in at least three other killings.
Before he is tried for those alleged crimes, prosecutors are trying Mendenhall for his alleged hiring of other inmates to kill five people, including two police detectives and three witnesses. Prosecutors say Mendenhall asked two cellmates to kill the five, who included witnesses Lori Young, David Powell and Richard Keim. Mendenhall also ordered hits on policemen Pat Postiglione and Mike Freemen, the two main investigators in Mendenhall’s original case.
Young spent four days riding in Mendenhall’s truck, and later moved to Albion, IL, and rented a house from Mendenhall. Powell, a convicted sex offender, and Keim both hung out with Mendenhall. Powell reportedly once dated Mendenhall’s daughter.
Since the arrest of Bruce D. Mendenhall of Albion, Ill., in July 2007 for the shooting death of a Nashville, Tenn., prostitute, officials have been monitoring closely the suspected serial killer’s mail and jailhouse phone calls. Mendenhall’s letters to and from his children and other relatives are now part of his growing case file.
Prosecutors in Nashville are trying to use evidence from those calls and letters to show that after Mendenhall was unsuccessful in establishing an alibi, he tried to hire two fellow inmates to kill people scheduled to testify against him in his upcoming murder trial.
Mendenhall’s defense team argued a motion last week to suppress the suspect’s letters to relatives, claiming the correspondence was “private” and not subject to seizure.
Since the arrest of Bruce D. Mendenhall of Albion, Ill., in July 2007 for the shooting death of a Nashville, Tenn., prostitute, officials have been monitoring closely the suspected serial killer’s mail and jailhouse phone calls. Mendenhall’s letters to and from his children and other relatives are now part of his growing case file.
Prosecutors in Nashville are trying to use evidence from those calls and letters to show that after Mendenhall was unsuccessful in establishing an alibi, he tried to hire two fellow inmates to kill people scheduled to testify against him in his upcoming murder trial.
Mendenhall’s defense team argued a motion last week to suppress the suspect’s letters to relatives, claiming the correspondence was “private” and not subject to seizure.
Investigators have given testimony that they obtained a subpoena to seize the letters. Mendenhall’s lawyer argued police needed a search warrant, and he has asked that the letters be barred from the trial. The judge is expected to rule on the motion later this week.
Since his arrest, Mendenhall has maintained that two former Albion men — Ritchie Keim and David Powell — have been following him around the country, killing several prostitutes at various truck stops.
Powell has told police he hadn’t seen Mendenhall since 2001 or 2002.
A Nashville, Tenn., judge has ruled that a 57-minute videotaped statement suspected serial killer Bruce Mendenhall made to police can be used at his upcoming trial on charges he tried to hire someone to kill two detectives and three witnesses in his upcoming murder trial.
Mendenhall is being held without bail in connection with the shooting death of Sarah Nicole Hulbert, 25, of Ashland City, Tenn. The truck driver from Albion, Ill., is also charged with murder in connection with the deaths of women whose bodies were found in Lebanon, Tenn., Birmingham, Ala., and Indianapolis.
In issuing the ruling, Davidson County Criminal Court Judge Steve Dozier ruled the two detectives who arrested Mendenhall at a truck stop in Nashville on July 12, 2007, did not violate his constitutional rights.
The solicitation for murder case against Mendenhall stems from statements from two inmates at the Nashville Criminal Justice Center.
In a letter written to Nashville Police Chief Ronald Serpas, inmate Michael Ray Jenkins, 55, details Mendenhall’s alleged request for Jenkins to kill the detectives who arrested Mendenhall — Pat Postiglione and Lee Freeman.
“He asked me if I wanted to earn some money,” Jenkins said. “Mr. Mendenhall offered to pay me $15,000 to kill two detectives who originally searched his truck. He wanted me to get the same caliber of pistol or gun in which he used in these murders and to shoot the two detectives with this gun so that it looked as if the person who did these murders of women was still out there.”
Jenkins, who was in custody on a probation violation offense, added Mendenhall told him that “now that his wife was dead that he had nothing more to lose and wanted vindication upon these two metro detectives on his murder case.”
Suspected serial killer Bruce D. Mendenhall of Albion, Ill., will go on trial in Nashville, Tenn., on Monday — not for murder, but for allegedly trying to hire hit men to kill two detectives and three witnesses in his upcoming murder trial.
During a hearing earlier this month, Mendenhall’s defense attorney argued that a videotaped interview with Nashville detectives in the hours after Mendenhall’s arrest for the murder of Sarah Nicole Hulbert should not be used in his solicitation of murder trial. The 57-minute interview, played for the first time in open court during the suppression of evidence hearing, shows Mendenhall blaming two Southern Illinois acquaintances for following him across the country, leaving a trail of dead bodies.
Mendenhall, 58, was arrested July 12, 2007, in Nashville. Detective Sgt. Pat Postiglione was acting on a hunch when he pulled into a truck stop to talk to the driver in the cab of a bright yellow semitrailer. Observing blood splatter on the door of the truck, Postiglione searched the vehicle and found a bag of bloody clothes.
The discovery resulted in Mendenhall’s arrest on a murder charge and launched an investigation that alleged the over-the-road trucker could be linked to the killing of seven or more women across the mid-South.
Early in the police interrogation, Mendenhall blamed two men that he claimed followed him across the country, committing murders.
The men, former Southern Illinois residents David Powell and Richie Kiem, face no charges in connection with Mendenhall’s alleged killings.
The jury hearing the case against accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall next week will not be sequestered, a judge ruled Monday.
Attorneys for Mendenhall, facing trial next week on five counts of solicitation to commit murder for allegedly trying to have witnesses and detectives from his murder case killed, asked in court filings Monday to keep the jury sequestered for the duration of the trial because of the publicity it will receive.
Davidson County Criminal Court Judge Steve Dozier said the request was too late for him to make arrangements.
“If I grant that motion we couldn’t have a trial Monday,” Dozier said. “I’ve got to find a hotel block of 20-plus rooms, make security aware, arrange for meals and call a sufficient jury pool.”
The judge did agree to individual questioning of each potential jury member, to ensure that someone who is familiar with the case doesn’t taint the jury pool, and said his direction to jury members to avoid news coverage will suffice.
Mendenhall, a long-haul truck driver from Albion, Ill., faces the death penalty in the June 2007 killing of Sara Hulbert. He also faces charges in three states in the slayings of four women. Investigators believe Mendenhall preyed on prostitutes who frequented truck stops and may be responsible for the deaths of at least six women. He has not been tried in any of the cases.
For the first time we hear from accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall. It’s an interview Mendenhall’s lawyers do not want jurors to hear. Police said Mendenhall killed seven prostitutes across the U.S. including one in Nashville and one in Lebanon.
The Illinois truck driver spoke with Metro Police Detective Pat Postiglione just hours after he was arrested in Nashville.
Metro has charged Mendenhall with killing Sara Hulbert. Her body was found at the Travel America truck stop in Downtown Nashville.
He blamed the murders on two men he said were following him from truck stop to truck stop.
Mendenhall talked about several murders and how some of the bodies ended up inside his 18-wheeler. Police said they have lots of physical evidence linking Mendenhall to the murders.
It was a long discussion in court Monday, just a week before Bruce Mendenhall is scheduled to stand trial on charges of trying to kill three witnesses and the two detectives.
Those detectives are the lead investigators in the murder case of Sara Hulbert, who Mendenhall is also charged with killing.
“I noticed some blood, a few drops of blood on the driver’s side door,” said Sgt. Pat Postiglione.
The defense questioned two Metro detectives about their actions on July 12, 2007, the day Mendenhall was arrested in connection with Hulbert’s death. Postiglione testified about what he found in Mendenhall’s truck at a Nashville truck stop.
“I noticed a large trash bag … between the bed and the driver’s seat, and I looked inside that bag, and I noticed what appeared to be blood-soaked items inside that bag,” he said.
At first, Postiglione said, Mendenhall had no explanation, but he later told more.
“He claimed not to be involved but claimed that these other people did it, and he claimed that they somehow knew what truck stop he would be at, show up at same truck stop, somehow find his weapon and kill the victims,” said Postiglione.
Mendenhall’s attorneys want those statements thrown out.
The defense questioned why Mendenhall was in custody for more than 2½ hours before his Miranda rights were read. But the state felt Mendenhall freely made those statements after his rights were read.
The defense also wants to suppress evidence from a wiretap conversation between two inmates. One inmate told the other about committing murders for money.
The defense argues the inmates were never identified by name so they can’t be sure the one talking about murder is Mendenhall, as the prosecution contends.
Prosecutors feel it shows Mendenhall’s motivation for why he wants the witnesses and officers killed.
Accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall was frustrated because he couldn’t line up alibis for a Nashville killing, prosecutors allege, and turned to soliciting the deaths of detectives and witnesses.
The state is trying to use evidence from letters and phone calls made by Mendenhall from prison to show the jury their theory of the crime: that after he couldn’t locate an alibi, real or fake, he turned to a murder plot to get rid of the people who would testify against him in the Sara Hulbert murder case.
A judge will decide whether to allow a jury to hear the evidence — hundreds of letters to family and pen pals talking about his need for an alibi as well as several recorded phone calls — in the trial scheduled to begin Nov. 16.
“All of this is relevant to his frame of mind,” prosecutor Rachel Sobrero said. “He’s trying to find an alibi. That doesn’t work. Months later, he’s hiring people to kill the witnesses.”
Hulbert was found dead in June 2007 at an East Nashville truck stop. Police arrested Mendenhall at the same truck stop less than three weeks later and said DNA evidence in his truck linked him to the murder.
In August 2008, Mendenhall was indicted on five counts of solicitation of murder for allegedly trying to hire two separate prison inmates to kill witnesses and Metro police detectives. One of the inmates, Roy McLaughlin, was wearing a wire.
Defense attorneys representing accused serial killer Bruce Mendenhall have asked for a delay in his Nashville murder trials, a postponement that could have a ripple effect on his other cases and the victims’ families who believe Mendenhall killed their loved ones.
Mendenhall faces the death penalty in Nashville in the killing of Sara Hulbert, who was 25 when she was found shot to death at a North First Street truck stop. Investigators believe Mendenhall, a long haul trucker, preyed on prostitutes who frequented truck stops and may be responsible for the deaths of at least six women.
While in jail, Mendenhall was charged with five counts of solicitation of murder on allegations that he tried to have two Metro detectives and three potential witnesses killed.
Mendenhall’s attorneys have asked that the two trials scheduled — for the solicitation charges in September and Hulbert’s death in January — be postponed because one of his attorneys is expecting a baby the week the first trial is scheduled. A request to hold two separate trials for the solicitation could also slow down progress to the capital case, now scheduled for January 2010.
“Death penalty cases are extremely serious, and we need to spend as much time as we can preparing for the trial,” said Dawn Deaner, Metro’s public defender. One of the attorneys assisting Deaner with Mendenhall’s cases is expecting the baby.